Home > Google > 7 Reasons Why The City of Los Angeles’ Move to Gmail Scares Me

7 Reasons Why The City of Los Angeles’ Move to Gmail Scares Me

In October 2009, The City of Los Angeles made a monumental business decision to switch its email (Outlook) and basic productivity products (Word, Excel, PowerPoint) to Gmail and Google Apps by June 2010. They cited cost savings as the main driver and I applaud them for such a gutsy move.

Despite unanimous approval from City Council, this move wasn’t without critics. Moving to Google means moving its emails out of City managed data centers and into a private cloud under Google’s surveillance. Issues concerning security and privacy naturally ensued, and both Google and the City published articles and webinars addressing these fears and articulating the additional benefits.

I have no qualms about moving to the cloud. My fear is around IMPLEMENTATION because we’re not just talking about going from chocolate to vanilla…

…we’re talking about ripping away a system that the majority of 30,000 employees have been using for many years, and forcing them to embrace a completely redesigned system that’s been turned on its ear.

I know training is stressed in their plan, but teaching what might be a large number of new users to learn Gmail is no small feat. Below are 7 aspects of Gmail that I hope gets extra attention in their training sessions.

1. There are only two places: “inbox” and “not-inbox”

This is probably the most difficult aspect to grasp for new users. When you want to move something out of the inbox, you don’t drag it into a folder, you tag it with however many labels that apply and then archive it. Gmail never uses the word “folder”. It’s either in your inbox or not. Expect to allow a lot of time for non-gmail regulars to adopt this concept.

2. Speaking of no folders, how do you get any structure?

I have some coworkers who are VERY proud of their well-architected hierarchical folder system. In Gmail, no hierarchy. New users better get used to the Search feature as the main way of retrieving archived mail.

3. Speaking of archived mail… why does it not mean archived mail?

In Outlook, archiving is for transferring the gargantuan weight of antiquated emails that you’ll probably never look at again. You don’t mess with it and just wait for it to automagically do its thing every few months. In Gmail, archive means scooting emails out of your inbox. That’s all. No big deal.

4. What about threaded conversations? That seems pretty intuitive

This is one of the low hanging fruits that make people fall in love with Gmail right away. Especially in government, we enjoy ridiculously long email trails. With threaded conversations, all that back and forth shrinks to one email in your inbox. But it does get tricky when the conversation branches. Sometimes you don’t want to reply all and it could get complicated. Expect a few oops from new users.

5. What about printing my emails?

Something else that government employees love to do… print emails. I don’t know why, but you’ll always find printed emails in the forgotten pile around print areas. With threaded conversations, some folks might not want to bother fishing through threaded conversations and just hit the “print all” button on the side. Or some will forget that if you just want to print one message, you’ll have to select from the drop down menu. Either way…printing could get tricky.

And two features that Google is touting that scares me

6. I can chat from my inbox? How awesome!

Many agencies already have instant messaging, but the reason it’s not ubiquitous is because agencies don’t want to deal with the policies. Now that it’s in Gmail, you’re instant message is automatically saved and searchable. Imagine what this does for e-discovery. Now when someone demands all records related a project, you can include all the chat conversations with it. And you know how professional people sound when they’re instant messaging… (that was sarcastic).

7. Google is proud of its storage space blowing away the competition

I’m not sure this is a good thing. Yes, it’s annoying to get the “Your mailbox is over capacity” email, but that forces employees to archive and delete deadweight. Now without that restriction, watch email management of attachments go even more crazily out of control.

Overall, I’ll be cheering the City of Los Angeles onwards in their endeavor, because I believe Gmail is superior to Outlook. But it’s so tremendously different that it will take a long time for the majority of new users to figure it out. Hopefully, with their extensive training plan, they can emerge as a pattern for other agencies to follow.

  1. Margo
    July 27, 2010 at 6:35 pm

    I like your thoughts! I wouldn’t say it’s “scary”, but I too am addicted to heirarchic folders in outlook. It would be tough for me to switch and I consider myself an advanced user.

    Good for LA!

    • Jon Lee
      July 27, 2010 at 9:26 pm

      Thanks for your comment, Margo. Considering the massive number of users that are forced to cutover to a new system, I think it can be potentially scary. I remember being on a small project of 7 people and we tried to get everyone to use Gmail, there was definitely some frustration because it took a few days to learn.

      • Margo
        July 29, 2010 at 12:29 pm

        I think the hardest part is not being able to drag-and-drop. If we could drag and drop emails onto labels on the left, and gmail would then label and archive, I would be happy.

        Otherwise, managing large volumes of email with check boxes would irritate me.

      • Jon Lee
        July 29, 2010 at 1:52 pm

        You can drag and drop into folders! Just mouse over to the left edge of the email and you’ll be able to drag into any label

  2. Kim
    July 28, 2010 at 6:23 pm

    There is hierarchy in the labeling system now! 🙂

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: